Searching over 5,500,000 cases.


searching
Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

Decker v. I.E. Miller Services, Inc.

United States District Court, D. North Dakota

February 14, 2018

Scot Decker, Plaintiff,
v.
I.E. Miller Services, Inc., et. al Defendants Party Designation Objection Ruling Allowed

          PATRICK HLADKY DEPOSITION RULINGS (FINAL)

          Charles S. Miller, Jr., Magistrate Judge United States District Court

         The following are the court's rulings with respect to the designations and objections by the parties for the presentation of the deposition testimony of the above-named witness.

Party
Designation
Objection
Ruling
Allowed
D
6/1-8/5
6/4-8/5
PCD
*6/4-6/12
D
8/23-17/16

P objects to 8/20 to 9/20 based on improper character evidence and remedial measures

P objects to 11/15-15/19 as relating to matter covered by order re motions in limine and irrelevant

P objects 15/20-15/24 as irrelevant sidebar

P objects 15/25-16/25 as being irrelevant, improper character evidence, and speculation

P objects to 17/01-17/16 same as above

Overruled

Sustained as to 11/15-12/18

Sustained as to 13/21-17/16 - Rules 402-03

See above See above

8/20-11/14 12/19-13/20
D
18/9-20/25

P objects to 18/09-18/18as irrelevant, improper character evidence, lacks foundation

P objects to remainder as irrelevant and subsequent remedial measures

Sustained Sustained

D
22/22-27/5

P objects to remedial measures, lack of foundation, speculation, lack of personal knowledge, and irrelevancy

Sustained in part and overruled in part

22/22-24/13 25/8-25/6
D
29/8-31/13

P objects lack of foundation and personal knowledge, speculation and irrelevancy

Sustained in part and overruled in part

30/10-30/24
D
32/5-33/21

Same as above

Sustained

D
34/10-35/13

Same as above

Sustained

D
35/22-35/25

Same as above

Sustained

D
39/7-40/15

Same as above

Sustained

PCD
44-06-44/13

Exclude part based on prior rulings

44/6-44/9
D
44/14-45/7

P objects hearsay, lack of relevance, speculation, improper character evidence

Sustained in part and overruled in part

44/22-45/7
D
45/23-46/21

P objects, lack of foundation and personal knowledge, speculation, improper character evidence and habit

Sustained in part and overruled in part

45/23-46/4 46/14-46/21
PCD
47/1-47/4
46/22-47/3
D
47/8-47/20
47/8-48/2
PCD
*47/8-47/10
PCD
*47/12-48/2
D
48/3-49/24

P objects to 48/03-48/20 as improper character evidence, lack of personal knowledge and foundation, and speculation

Overruled

48/3-49/24
PCD
51/3-51/8
51/3-51/8
D
54/6-57/22

P objects as irrelevant, habit, lack of personal knowledge and foundation, hearsay, and speculation

Sustained on 402 and 403 grounds

D
64/21-69/8

P objects to 65/12-65/12??

P objects to 66/11-69/08 as irrelevant, improper character evidence, lacks foundation, not the same type of work

Overruled

Sustained per rulings on motions in limine and Rule 407

64/21-65-22
PCD
*65/12-65/22
D
96/8-96/21

P objects as irrelevant, lacks foundation, dissimilar accidents

Sustained

D
99/18-100/17

P objects to 99/18-100/8 as irrelevant, lacks foundation, improper character evidence

Overruled in part and also based on counter-designation

99/18-100/24
PCD
*100/9-100/24
PCD
103/1-103/4
103/1-103/4
PCD
103/18-104/7

D objects speculation and Rule 401-03 grounds

Sustained

PCD
104/10-104/13

Same as above

Sustained

PCD
104/24-105/4
104/24-105/4
PCD
108/17-109/1

Same as above

Overruled

108/17-109/1
PCD
109/4-109/8
109/4-109/8
PCD
110/9-112/14

D objects to speculation, Rule 401-03 grounds and form objections in the record

Sustained in part and overruled in part

111/3-112/14
PCD
113/1-113/15
113/1-113/15
PCD
116/10-117/13
116/10-117/13
PCD
120/18-121/15
PCD
126/2-126/20
PCD
127/8-127/17

D objects 127/8 to 129/8 based on speculation and misleading

Sustained and Rule 403 unless can show that test was conducted

DCD
127/18-127/20

See above

See above

PCD
127/21-129/8

See above

See above

PCD
132/24-133/14
132/24-133/13
DCD
133/14-135/14
133/14-135/14
PCD
138/8-138/14
138/8-138/14
DCD
138/15-138/17
138/15-138/17
PCD
144/22-144/25
144/22-144/25
PCD
145/12-145/14
145/12-145/14
PCD
146/19-146/22
146/19-146/22
PCD
150/6-150/23

D objects as speculation, confusing, and Rule 401-403 grounds

Sustained

PCD
171/20-173/1
171/20-173/1
PCD
173/24-175/2

D objects on grounds that questions are vague and compound as well as speculation and assuming facts not in evidence

Sustained

PCD
181/4-181/13
181/4-181/13
PCD
182/6-182/10
182/6-182/10
DCD
182/23-185/13 183/23-185/13
183/23-185/13
PCD
185/14-185/24
185/14-185/24
DCD
185/25-186/19
185/25-186/19
PCD
186/20-187/4
186/20-187/4
DCD
187/5-187/17
187/5-187/17
PCD
188/4-188/8
188/4-188/8
DCD
188/9-189/14
188/9-189/14
DCD
190/23-192/1
190/23-192/1
PCD
194/22-196/6 194/22-195/6

D objects to this because it assumes someone other than driller acted

Overruled

194/22-195/6
PCD
202/22-203/11

D objects based on form objection in record and argumentative

Sustained

PCD
205/2-205/20
205/2-205/20
PCD
206/11-206/17
206/11-206/17
PCD
207/11-209/4

D objects on lack of relevancy and Rule 401-03 grounds

Sustained in part and overruled in part

208/14-209/4
D
233/10-235/20

P objects as irrelevant, hearsay, calls for speculation, and improper character evidence

Sustained in part and overruled in part

233/10-233/16 235/11-235/20
D
236/13-239/11

P objects as irrelevant, lacks personal knowledge, speculation, and character evidence

Sustained in part and overruled in part

236/13-238/2 238/10-239/11
D
240/17-241/25

P objects to 241/2 to 241/25 on same grounds as above

Sustained

240/17-241/1
PCD
*240/19-241/01
D
244/23-245/13

Exclude relevancy and 403 grounds and ruling on subsequent objections???? what is ex.30

D
246/7-247/1

P objects calls, for speculation, lack of personal knowledge, and foundation

Exclude relevancy and 403 grounds

D
260/19-261/20

P objects as irrelevant, improper character evidence, and violating order re motion in limine

Sustained in part and overruled in part and P opened door

260/19-261/3 261/6-261/14

         IT ...


Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.